Perek 8
The differences between Beith Shamai and Beith Hillel in the meal.
kiddush and the order of the brachoth:
B"S says that the blessing of the day comes first
because:
- It is the sanctification of the day that causes the blessing over the wine
- cause takes precedence over effect
- cause should precede effect
- The day is, de facto, sanctified prior to the blessing on the wine
- the order of blessings reflects the facts
- the day would receive its blessing, even in the absences of wine ( or bread)
- establishing the day's priority
Beith Hillel says that blessing over the wine comes first
because
- The wine is a prerequisite to the kiddush
- in the absence of wine, there would be no kiddush
- necessity is recognized by precedence
- preventing the accidental (aborted) kiddush in the absence of wine
- wine is drunk more frequently than kiddush is said
- frequency dictates precedence
The question is which principle(s) are the priority

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home